Menu Close

Expected Changes in Obesity after Reformulation to Reduce Added Sugars in Beverages: A Modeling Study


Basto-Abreu, Ana; Braverman-Bronstein, Ariela; Camacho-Garcia-Formenti, Dalia; Zepeda-Tello, Rodrigo; Popkin, Barry M.; Rivera-Dommarco, Juan; Hernandez-Avila, Mauricio; & Barrientos-Gutierrez, Tonatiuh (2018). Expected Changes in Obesity after Reformulation to Reduce Added Sugars in Beverages: A Modeling Study. PLOS Medicine, 15(10), e1002664. PMCID: PMC6173390


BACKGROUND: Several strategies have been proposed to reduce the intake of added sugars in the population. In Mexico, a 10% sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) tax was implemented in 2014, and the implementation of other nutritional policies, such as product reformulation to reduce added sugars, is under discussion. WHO recommends that all individuals consume less than 10% of their total energy intake (TEI) from added sugars. We propose gradually reducing added sugars in SSBs to achieve an average 10% consumption of added sugars in the Mexican population over 10 years and to estimate the expected impact of reformulation in adult body weight and obesity.
METHODS AND FINDINGS: Baseline consumption for added sugars and SSBs, sex, age, socioeconomic status (SES), height, and weight for Mexican adults were obtained from the 2012 Mexico National Health and Nutrition Survey (ENSANUT). On average, 12.6% of the TEI was contributed by added sugars; we defined a 50% reduction in added sugars in SSBs over 10 years as a reformulation target. Using a dynamic weight change model, sugar reductions were translated into individual expected changes in body weight assuming a 43% caloric compensation and a 2-year lag for the full effect of reformulation to occur. Results were stratified by sex, age, and SES. Twelve years after reformulation, the TEI from added sugars is expected to decrease to 10%, assuming no compensation from added sugars; 44% of the population would still be above WHO recommendations, requiring further sugar reductions to food. Body weight could be reduced by 1.3 kg (95% CI -1.4 to -1.2) in the adult population, and obesity could decrease 3.9 percentage points (pp; -12.5% relative to baseline). Our sensitivity analyses suggest that the impact of the intervention could vary from 0.12 kg after 6 months to 1.52 kg in the long term.
CONCLUSIONS: Reformulation to reduce added sugars in SSBs could produce large reductions in sugar consumption and obesity in the Mexican adult population. This study is limited by the use of a single dietary recall and by data collected in all seasons except summer; still, these limitations should lead to conservative estimates of the reformulation effect. Reformulation success could depend on government enforcement and industry and consumer response, for which further research and evidence are needed.


Reference Type

Journal Article

Year Published


Journal Title

PLOS Medicine

Series Title

A Basto-Abreu et al. PLoS Med 16 (1), e1002743. 2019. PMID 30677021.


Basto-Abreu, Ana
Braverman-Bronstein, Ariela
Camacho-Garcia-Formenti, Dalia
Zepeda-Tello, Rodrigo
Popkin, Barry M.
Rivera-Dommarco, Juan
Hernandez-Avila, Mauricio
Barrientos-Gutierrez, Tonatiuh