Skip to main content


Mendel, Jennifer R.; Baig, Sabeeh A.; Hall, Marissa G.; Jeong, Michelle; Byron, M. Justin; Morgan, Jennifer C.; Noar, Seth M.; Ribisl, Kurt M.; & Brewer, Noel T. (2018). Brand Switching and Toxic Chemicals in Cigarette Smoke: A National Study. PLOS ONE, 13(1), e0189928. PMCID: PMC5764241


INTRODUCTION: US law requires disclosure of quantities of toxic chemicals (constituents) in cigarette smoke by brand and sub-brand. This information may drive smokers to switch to cigarettes with lower chemical quantities, under the misperception that doing so can reduce health risk. We sought to understand past brand-switching behavior and whether learning about specific chemicals in cigarette smoke increases susceptibility to brand switching.
METHODS: Participants were US adult smokers surveyed by phone (n = 1,151, probability sample) and online (n = 1,561, convenience sample). Surveys assessed whether smokers had ever switched cigarette brands or styles to reduce health risk and about likelihood of switching if the smoker learned their brand had more of a specific chemical than other cigarettes. Chemicals presented were nicotine, carbon monoxide, lead, formaldehyde, arsenic, and ammonia.
RESULTS: Past brand switching to reduce health risk was common among smokers (43% in phone survey, 28% in online survey). Smokers who were female, over 25, and current "light" cigarette users were more likely to have switched brands to reduce health risks (all p < .05). Overall, 61-92% of smokers were susceptible to brand switching based on information about particular chemicals. In both samples, lead, formaldehyde, arsenic, and ammonia led to more susceptibility to switch than nicotine (all p < .05).
CONCLUSIONS: Many US smokers have switched brands or styles to reduce health risks. The majority said they might or would definitely switch brands if they learned their cigarettes had more of a toxic chemical than other brands. Brand switching is a probable unintended consequence of communications that show differences in smoke chemicals between brands.


Reference Type

Journal Article

Year Published


Journal Title



Mendel, Jennifer R.
Baig, Sabeeh A.
Hall, Marissa G.
Jeong, Michelle
Byron, M. Justin
Morgan, Jennifer C.
Noar, Seth M.
Ribisl, Kurt M.
Brewer, Noel T.